For years, forced labor import bans have been viewed by many coffee companies as a remote legal concern. That perspective is changing, and quickly.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) issued its first import ban focused on the coffee sector earlier this year, sending a clear warning that coffee is no longer outside the reach of forced labor enforcement. Additionally, forced labor import bans are rapidly expanding around the globe, with the EU Forced Labor Regulation (EUFLR) coming into full force next year.
These developments are part of a broader shift. While forced labor bans are being adopted by a significant number of countries, governments are also enacting human rights due diligence (HRDD) legislation requiring companies to identify, prevent and address human rights risks in their supply chains.
These measures differ in scope and enforcement, but they are part of the same transformation: companies are increasingly expected to know where serious risks exist in their supply chains and demonstrate what they are doing about them. Or, in other words, have a viable HRDD system.
Business Risks
For coffee traders, roasters, brands and retailers, forced labor import bans matter for a variety of reasons. A shipment linked to forced labor can be detained at the border, disrupting supply and delaying deliveries. As a result, companies may face lost sales, legal and compliance costs, reputational harm, damage to customer relationships and increased scrutiny from investors, consumers, the press and activists.
If a company seeks to challenge an import ban, it needs credible evidence showing that the goods were not produced with forced labor. An effective due diligence system can produce this type of evidence, by the time a shipment is detained, it is far too late to start building and implementing an HRDD system.
Where Traditional Due Diligence Falls Short
Forced labor risks that can lead to a shipment being detained are not always visible to buyers, especially in extended supply chains. Many companies build their due diligence systems around superficial salience assessments, adverse-media scans, certifications, audits and supplier self-assessments. Each can contribute useful information to a due diligence process, but they often do not provide all the information a company needs to effectively identify forced labor risk.
In places that lack a robust civil society and press presence, or where government oversight and transparency are insufficient, severe problems can remain largely invisible to adverse media scans and salience assessments. Likewise, certification inspections and traditional audits can miss many cases of forced labor, as they do not involve in-depth interviews with a representative cross-section of workers in areas in which they can freely share sensitive information without risk of reprisal.
Furthermore, these services often fail to focus on the indicators of forced labor — the specific practices that together result in forced labor — such as deceptive recruitment, forced overtime, debt bondage, and wage and document retention. These deficiencies highlight why worker-informed, field-based research that includes confidential off-site interviews and engagement with trusted local organizations is essential to understanding forced labor risk.
Building More Effective Due Diligence Systems
The message from governments around the world is abundantly clear: coffee buyers must develop their own robust HRDD systems and build the capacity of their suppliers — coffee traders, cooperatives and farmers — to effectively detect and address forced labor risks. Buyers are responsible for providing their suppliers with practical tools, guidance and resources to effectively implement robust HRDD systems that effectively detect, address and prevent forced labor. Additionally, buyers should examine how their own purchasing practices, including prices, timelines and production expectations, may exacerbate risks at the farm level.
No company can eliminate forced labor risk through a single action or even a series of disconnected ones. What companies can do is build systems that effectively and consistently identify the most serious risks and support sustained remediation.
For the coffee industry, forced labor import bans and emerging due diligence requirements should not be treated as separate compliance exercises. They are part of a wider movement toward meaningful accountability for working conditions throughout global supply chains. Coffee companies that invest now, proactively, in HRDD will be better prepared to protect workers, maintain market access and meet rising legal and commercial expectations.
If you are looking for a place to start, there are open-access tools and guidance on the development of HRDD systems appropriate for the agricultural sector, such as the Farm Labor Due Diligence Toolkit, as well as on identifying and addressing forced labor and child labor risks in the coffee sector specifically, such as the Cooperation On Fair, Free, Equitable Employment (COFFEE) Toolkit.
Editor’s Note: The author is affiliated with Verité, the nonprofit organization that developed the two due diligence toolkits referenced in this column. Daily Coffee News chose to retain links to resources published online by Verité because they are freely available, developed through collaborative initiatives and provide practical guidance relevant to the issues discussed. Their inclusion does not constitute an endorsement of Verité or its services. Daily Coffee News does not engage in sponsored content or affiliate linking of any kind. Any statements or opinions expressed belong solely to the author/s and do not necessarily reflect the views of Daily Coffee News or its management.
Comments? Questions? News to share? Contact DCN’s editors here. For all the latest coffee industry news, subscribe to the DCN newsletter.
Related Posts
Quinn Kepes
Quinn Kepes is the Managing Director of Research and Strategic Initiatives at Verité, where he has worked for over 20 years providing businesses, investors, governments, intergovernmental organizations, workers, and civil society organizations the knowledge and tools that they need to eliminate the most serious labor and human rights abuses from global supply chains. He began working in the coffee sector in 2008 and has conducted and directed field research on labor issues on coffee farms in Mexico, Guatemala, Honduras, Colombia, Brazil, and Uganda. He has also directed a number of company, foundation, and government-funded projects to identify, address, and prevent human rights risks in the coffee sector, including the U.S. Department of Labor-funded Cooperation On Fair, Free, Equitable Employment (COFFEE) Project.


Comment