Skip to main content

Founder Eileen Rinaldi Comes Full Circle at Ritual Coffee’s New San Francisco Cafe

Ritual Coffee California SF

The new Ritual Coffee cafe at California and Battery street’s in San Francisco’s FiDi. Photo by Lucas Saugen, courtesy of Ritual Coffee.

San Francisco-based roaster-retailer Ritual Coffee opened a new cafe in the city’s Financial District in late October in the very same place where founder and CEO Eileen Rinaldi worked her first Bay Area coffee job 23 years ago.

On the ground floor of the iconic 14-story 255 Cal building, the spacious and light-filled cafe boasts floor-to-ceiling windows and details inspired by classic Italian coffee bars and the midcentury building itself.

Ritual Coffee California bar

Photo by Lucas Saugen, courtesy of Ritual Coffee.

Ritual worked with local architect Seth Boor to peel away layers added during the space’s roughly 20 years as a Starbucks, exposing board-formed concrete and original travertine pillars while adding warmth with new wood elements. The bells and rumbles of passing San Francisco cable cars now mingle once again with the hum of grinders and whoosh of steamed milk as baristas work on a new La Marzocco GB5 espresso machine.

“Honestly, it feels like a dream come true,” Rinaldi told Daily Coffee News. “The cafe space has such a good energy to it. You can watch the cable cars going by, and there is a ton of foot traffic.”

Ritual Coffee California espresso

Photo by Lucas Saugen, courtesy of Ritual Coffee.

Espresso-based specials for the shop’s opening season include an apple pie-inspired latte called the Oak & Apple, flavored with Gravenstein apple butter and spices blended by Oaktown Spice Shop. Drinks in the 1,800-square-foot cafe are served alongside pastries from local Saltwater Bakeshop and doughnuts from Dynamo Donut.

Grab-and-go breakfast sandwiches are also offered, along with batch-brewed coffee from a Fetco system. Eight- and 12-ounce Hario V60 pourovers are available, as is a larger “for two” option brewed in a Kalita Wave. All coffees pass through Ritual’s vintage Probat roaster at its SoMa roastery. 

Ritual Coffee California donuts

Photo by Lucas Saugen, courtesy of Ritual Coffee.

Before it became a Starbucks, the corner location held one of four San Francisco outposts of Torrefazione Italia, the coffee chain founded by an Italian immigrant in Seattle that merged with Seattle’s Best Coffee in 1994 and was later acquired by Starbucks. Rinaldi worked her way from barista to manager for Torrefazione Italia in Seattle before moving to California to manage its busiest shop at the corner of California and Battery streets.

While she kept the high-volume cafe on its tracks five days per week, her free time involved writing a business plan and scouting locations for a coffee company she hoped to build. Starbucks’ 2003 acquisition of Torrefazione Italia’s parent company accelerated that transition, and in 2004 Rinaldi signed a lease for what would become Ritual’s first cafe on Valencia street. 

Ritual Coffee California pourover

Photo by Lucas Saugen, courtesy of Ritual Coffee.

Ritual Coffee has meanwhile expanded and contracted over the years, most recently closing several San Francisco locations before cautiously growing again. The FiDi shop is its first new standalone cafe since opening a Castro location in 2017, a year after opening in Haight-Ashbury in 2016. Both earlier locations have since closed.

Ritual now operates three cafes in San Francisco, one in Napa and one at San Francisco International Airport.

Rinaldi said the company’s next focus will be expanding its food program, with more production moving in-house in 2027.

Ritual Coffee California rail

Photo by Lucas Saugen, courtesy of Ritual Coffee.

Ritual Coffee is located at 259 California St. in San Francisco.


Comments? Questions? News to share? Contact DCN’s editors here. For all the latest coffee industry news, subscribe to the DCN newsletter.

Comment