Skip to main content

Wanderlust Coffee Turns a Corner with Second Indiana Cafe

Wanderlust Coffee West Lafayette 2

The new Wanderlust Coffee shop in West Lafayette, Indiana. All images courtesy of Wanderlust Coffee.

Wanderlust Coffee has opened its second cafe in West Lafayette, Indiana, offering elements that may be be familiar to fans of Wanderlust’s original location in Lafayette while venturing into some new territory.

Near the Purdue Research Park, the new 1,800-square-foot cafe offers a smaller version of the original lending library, while the menu of drinks, pastries and bagels is largely the same. As at the first shop, a large mural of a barista at work towers over the new shop’s high-ceilinged space. Yet in its fundamental design, the new shop wanders down a different path. 

“It feels more grown-up and more refined, but not in a way that feels too serious,” Wanderlust Coffee Founder Walt Cornelius told Daily Coffee News. “The new shop feels like a natural next step from the original. They are different in style and scale, but they share the same goal, to make people feel comfortable, cared for and excited about the coffee.”

Wanderlust Coffee West Lafayette 1

Cornelius, who hand-built the bar and other fixtures in the first cafe, said the second shop began with a bar designed to feel like a large, heavy block of concrete anchoring the room.

A La Marzocco GB5 with custom carmine-red accents is matched by pops of color throughout the space. Locally made black steel tables add another raw, industrial note, balanced by herringbone wood seating, plants, warm lighting and other organic textures.

“For me, the goal was to push the edge of a brutalist-inspired cafe without letting it feel cold or uninviting,” Cornelius said. “The result is a space that feels modern and design-forward, but still comfortable — a place where the coffee, the bar, and the room all feel connected.”

Open since January, the new shop arrived almost exactly two years after Wanderlust’s first. In the interim, the company’s roasting shifted from a 2-kilogram-capacity Buckeye roaster in Brookston to a Bellwether Series 2 machine that Cornelius said will soon be replaced by a Probat P12.

Near Purdue University in a fast-changing part of West Lafayette, the new shop serves a mix of students, professionals and families. Behind the bar are the 3-group GB5, a Mahlkönig E65 GBW for espresso and Marco batch brew and cold brew systems paired with a Mahlkönig EK43.

“Coffee is the reason people come in, but hospitality is what makes them feel like they belong,” Cornelius said. “We want every person who walks through the door to feel respected, welcomed and cared for, regardless of who they are or where they come from.”

Wanderlust Coffee West Lafayette 3

Moving forward, a 1975 Winnebago coffee truck remains a work in progress, as is a dedicated bakery that would allow the company to expand its wholesale services farther into Indiana.

“The original shop helped us figure out who we were,” Cornelius said. “The new shop shows where we are headed.”

Wanderlust Coffee is located at 1020 Gemini Lane #150, in West Lafayette.


Comments? Questions? News to share? Contact DCN’s editors here. For all the latest coffee industry news, subscribe to the DCN newsletter.

Comment