The California state agency that implements the Proposition 65 law is proposing to exempt coffee from the list of products requiring cancer warnings, saying coffee poses “no significant risk.”
The unprecedented amendment by the California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) would undermine a controversial California Superior Court ruling in March that requires coffee sellers to include a Prop 65 cancer warning, despite a lack of evidence associating coffee with increased incidence of cancer, and plenty of evidence suggesting coffee may actually prevent certain cancers.
The World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer removed coffee from its list of “possibly carcinogenic” food items in 2016. And in 2015, an agency within the USDA officially suggested drinking coffee is healthy.
The Prop 65 amendment for coffee would be a major win for the industry. About 90 coffee companies in California were named in an initial lawsuit in 2010 filed by a nonprofit composed of lawyers. While many of those companies have settled out of court, the Superior Court ruling by judge Elihu Berle opened coffee companies up to fines for each “exposure” consumers had to coffee since 2002.
The ruling also resulted in widespread confusion among consumers, who in California are seeing cancer warnings associated with their morning coffee, while being told by other government agencies that coffee is essentially a health drink that may prevent cancer.
“Proposition 65, approved by California voters in 1986, is a right-to-know law that requires businesses to provide clear and reasonable warnings when they knowingly cause exposures to chemicals that the state has listed as causing cancer or reproductive effects. The law has prompted the reduction or elimination of lead, arsenic and other toxic chemicals in a variety of products,” OEHHA wrote in the announcement of the proposed coffee exemption for Prop 65. “However, the statute does not require cancer warnings when exposure to listed chemicals does not cause a significant cancer risk.
“While the proposed regulation would largely exempt coffee from Proposition 65 cancer warnings, it does not address exposures to listed chemicals that may occur if the chemicals are intentionally added to the coffee mixture or enter the mixture as contaminants in some way other than the process of roasting and brewing.”
The proposed amendment includes a comment period that will run through Aug. 30, and a public hearing is scheduled for Thursday, Aug. 16. See OEHHA for more details.
Nick Brown is the editor of Daily Coffee News by Roast Magazine.